Political Parties Dispute Resolution tribunal has extended the interim orders issued on April 28th stopping the Party of National Unity (PNU) from issuing certificates to the primaries nominees for various seats in Embu County until the hearing and determination of the complaint.
While delivering the ruling, tribunal chair Kyalo Mbobu said that in light of the letter dated April 24th addressed to the party by the complainants which to date has not been acted upon by the party, the claimants have conformed with the requirements to invoke the party’s internal dispute resolution mechanism.
Lawyer Apollo Muinde for the four PNU members Denis Mugendi, Jeremiah Mugambi Njagi, Patrick Mucira Wilson and Simon Njue Gitegua told the tribunal that the nomination exercise was a sham.
Mr Muinde urged the tribunal to order a repeat of the nomination exercise since it was tainted with violence, bribery and open campaigns during the nomination.
“ The presiding officers arrived the polling stations after 5pm and thousands and thousands of voters who were at the stations since morning were turned away without exercising their democratic rights of electing candidates if their choice,” Muinde told the tribunal.
He added that some of the names for various MCA aspirants in the area were missing from the ballot papers despite them having paid the necessary fees.
The party members are also seeking to have the primaries in Embu declared null and void having been tainted with massive fraud and gross irregularities.
Earlier an attempt by PNU to have the matter struck out for none compliance with PNU Constitution on dispute resolution was dismissed.
The tribunal agreed with Mr Muinde that the PNU did not follow the due process to resolve the issue.
The tribunal was presided over by Kyalo Mbobu (chairman), James Atemi and Aldeline Mbithi.
The PNU members among them Embu gubernatorial aspirant Dr Cyrus Njiru flocked the tribunal’s hearing session to show their support to the complainants.
while addressing the media outside Milimani law courts,
The tribunal also ordered the defendants to file their response on or before May 1st 2017.
The matter will be heard on Tuesday, April 2nd 2017 in the morning and the ruling delivered in the afternoon on the same day as it is a matter of urgency.
Wajir County Governor Mohamed Abdi has lost his seat after high court nullified his win.
While delivering the judgment, Justice Alfred Mabeya ruled that the Governor did not have the appropriate academic qualification required to run for office.
The therefore ruled that Abdi was not legally cleared to run for office.
Justice Mabeya said that the Governor failed to prove that ‘his degree’ was valid.
He added that as of regards to the masters degree in Diplomacy and International Relations, the court took judicial notice that one cannot obtain a master’s degree before obtaining a bachelors one.
“As of 3rd September 2014, the first respondent had not yet graduated with any degree, therefore, it is not possible that he would have obtained a master’s degree six months later on 12th March 2015,” the judge ruled.
The judge added that the petitioners, former Wajir Governor Ahmed Abdullahi and Muhumed Abdi proved the qualification allegation to the required standard.
“In my view, the first respondent failed to show that he had actually obtained the two degrees from Kampala University,” said the judge.
Governor’s failure to attend court
Justice Mabeya also took notice that although the Governor had the opportunity to either deny or challenge the allegations, he did not do so in his replying affidavit and also failed to appear in court to shed light on the issue.
He added that the totality of irregularities that were proved were so grave that they not only affected the credibility of the election but also the results of the election itself.
Irregularities proved
On the issue of irregularities, the judge faulted the returning officer for opening ballot boxes that had already been sealed, contrary to the law.
The court noted that a huge number of voters in Wajir are illiterate and were assisted to vote.
Justice Mabeya ruled that it was wrong for the presiding officers to ask assisted voters to shout the name of the candidate they were to vote for.
This therefore shows that there was irregular and unprocedaral assistance of voters which compromised the voting,” ruled the judge.
In his judgement, the judge also awarded two million shillings to the petitioners as costs.
He also ordered a by-election to be held in accordant with the election laws and the constitution.
Petitioners lawyers Omwanza Ombati (left) and Jesse Oduor (right) during delivery of the judgment.
In the petition, Ahmed and Muhumed wanted the court to nullify the election of Abdi on grounds that the election was marred by massive irregularities
Through lawyers Omwanza Ombati and Jesse Oduor, the two claimed that the governor and/or his people used violence and intimidated their agents and the integrity if the process was undermined therefore affecting the outcome of the election
The petitioners argued that the constitutional and statutory disqualification of the Governor to contest in the elections means his nomination as a candidate and subsequent election was invalid, null and void.